
Here is the review I posted on Goodreads. I intend to post it on Amazon as well but this far there are technical difficulties…
Special thanks to my Israeli friend Davida Chazan, who as The Chocolate Lady is a book reviewer herself. I asked for her advice and she gave me good counsel.
Note/Warning: The police violence explicitly described in this review may be triggering to some.
Susan Vespoli lost her son Adam on March 12, 2022. Donnell Lindo, who at the time was a police officer for the City of Phoenix, saw Adam get into the police cruiser that Lindo had left unlocked, and he drew his gun while running toward the vehicle and fired three shots through the window. The cruiser ended up crashing against a tree. Adam was pulled from the car, and CPR was administered, but in vain.
Vespoli is on record as claiming that her writing is necessary to her sanity. It is no surprise, then, that this most tragic and wrenching of life events spurred a flurry of writing; and that’s how this book came to be.
As it happens, Vespoli has been trained to be a teacher in a timed-prompt writing process called Wild Writing. This new book of hers contains some of the wildest, most primal writing she has ever done, an improbable mesh of open-wound emotion and the precise, crystalline structure and word choice available to a poet who has been working hard on her craft for years.
In her poem “After I Read Poems About Addiction in My Family,” she tells of a woman who attended her reading and then demanded, “What makes you think it’s okay to write and share these kinds of poems?” She riposted the woman’s aggression with
“Because I believe in telling the truth
with love and I believe we’re as sick as our secrets
and I believe burying your story can kill
you and I believe that writing it out can heal.”
Those four lines, so elegantly different as conversation versus poetry, even though the words are the same, exemplify Vespoli’s wild/quiet skill. The first line ends with “telling the truth” and line 2 begins “with love.” A lesser poet would have ended the first line with “telling the truth with love.” But Vespoli knows that her reader will microscopically pause between lines. She uses that pause for a crucial emphasis on the telling of truth. Lest we imagine that is coincidental, she ends line 3 with “burying your story can kill” instead of “burying your story can kill you.” She achieves deeper meaning with that well-chosen line break, one that is eerily apt to the police violence we have had unearthed more and more in recent times. Had the bus cam not recorded that crucial few seconds between Adam’s approach and entry into the police cruiser and then-Officer Lindo’s discharging his firearm at point blank range, the account Lindo gave, claiming he felt his life was in imminent danger, and the absurdity of the description given to media by the police that Adam was trying to steal the cruiser, might have been the accepted narrative of record. But Adam’s death viewed from the impartiality of the bus cam gives such a depth to the pair of text messages Adam had sent to his mother, the first a mere matter of weeks before his death, and the second in 2021:
“I think god has another plan for my life.”
“I want to share it with the world someday
and I believe that is part of my purpose.”
Consequences related to Adam’s death by violence include the ending of Donnell Lindo’s career as a police officer; the Phoenix Police Department soliciting public input on their policy related to the use of deadly force; and the creation of this astonishing volume that is excellent poetry, but so much more. Vespoli has made a portrait of her beloved son that reveals him as a caring, struggling, vulnerable human being with love in his heart and a journey that we see was derailed tragically. Vespoli takes the book’s title from this that she said in an author’s statement:
“Every homeless person you pass on the street or in the park is someone’s beloved kid. One of them was mine.”
Please add this valuable book to your library. Vespoli is donating any profits it accrues to The National Coalition for the Homeless, Mothers Against Police Brutality, and other advocacy groups. And reading the gripping poems will break your heart in the best possible way.
